Largest auto insurance companies in the US: the top 25 by premiums and market share

State Farm and Progressive are now level in car insurance, $158 million apart on $69 billion each, and the next three write more than the following 20 combined. This list ranks insurers on personal auto alone, the way regulators measure them, and adds the loss ratio and sales channel that tell a seller where to start.

Company list9 min readPublished

See the list Ready now. Free to look, no signup.
Ready now. Free to look.

The largest auto insurance companies in the US by 2025 private passenger auto premiums are State Farm ($69.2 billion written, 18.64% market share), Progressive ($69.0 billion, 18.60%), Berkshire Hathaway's GEICO group ($42.9 billion, 11.56%), Allstate ($37.7 billion, 10.15%) and USAA ($23.0 billion, 6.19%), according to the NAIC. Together they wrote 65.14% of the $371.0 billion market. The ranking counts insurance groups, including mutuals and reciprocals that file no 10-K.

  • State Farm wrote $158 million more personal auto premium than Progressive in 2025, a gap of 0.04 points of market share.
  • The top 10 groups wrote 76.88% of the $371.0 billion market and the top 25 wrote 88.68%.
  • Loss ratios in the top 25 ranged from 47.17% at Liberty Mutual to 82.88% at the Automobile Club of Michigan group, against 61.49% for the industry.
  • Sixteen of the 25 largest auto groups file no 10-K; together they wrote 42.22% of the market.
  • In commercial auto, Progressive leads with 13.20%, more than twice Travelers' 5.46%.
On this page

This list is for anyone who sells to auto insurers (claims and repair networks, glass and rental, telematics and pricing data, agency software, marketing and IT) and for anyone who wants to know who the biggest car insurers are. It ranks insurance groups by private passenger auto premiums written in 2025, from the market share data the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) compiles from every insurer's statutory filings. That source covers mutuals, reciprocal exchanges and AAA clubs, which file no 10-K, so they appear beside the listed companies. For every line of insurance and total revenue, see the top insurance companies.

The 25 largest auto insurance companies in the US

RankGroupHeadquartersDirect premiums written, 2025Market shareDirect loss ratioFiles a 10-K
1State FarmBloomington, IL$69.16B18.64%65.44%No
2ProgressiveMayfield Village, OH$69.01B18.60%59.07%Yes (PGR)
3Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO)Omaha, NE$42.91B11.56%67.14%Yes (BRK)
4AllstateNorthbrook, IL$37.67B10.15%55.64%Yes (ALL)
5USAASan Antonio, TX$22.96B6.19%67.35%No
6FarmersWoodland Hills, CA$13.24B3.57%51.49%No
7Liberty MutualBoston, MA$10.41B2.81%47.17%No
8TravelersNew York, NY$7.16B1.93%53.63%Yes (TRV)
9Auto Club EnterprisesCosta Mesa, CA$7.05B1.90%67.91%No
10American FamilyMadison, WI$5.69B1.53%59.83%No
11Erie InsuranceErie, PA$5.27B1.42%73.05%Its manager, Erie Indemnity (ERIE)
12Auto-OwnersLansing, MI$5.16B1.39%58.39%No
13CSAA (AAA)Walnut Creek, CA$5.07B1.37%62.91%No
14NationwideColumbus, OH$4.07B1.10%51.59%No
15Mercury GeneralLos Angeles, CA$3.56B0.96%57.99%Yes (MCY)
16Sentry (The General)Stevens Point, WI$3.07B0.83%56.00%No
17KemperChicago, IL$2.98B0.80%65.56%Yes (KMPR)
18Automobile Club of Michigan groupDearborn, MI$2.65B0.71%82.88%No
19The HartfordHartford, CT$2.32B0.62%57.80%Yes (HIG)
20NJMWest Trenton, NJ$1.74B0.47%70.20%No
21Amica MutualLincoln, RI$1.64B0.44%58.28%No
22ShelterColumbia, MO$1.59B0.43%58.23%No
23COUNTRY FinancialBloomington, IL$1.58B0.42%55.73%No
24MAPFREMadrid, Spain$1.54B0.42%60.53%No
25The HanoverWorcester, MA$1.52B0.41%62.02%Yes (THG)

Premiums, shares and loss ratios: NAIC 2025 top 25 groups by countrywide premium, total private passenger auto, based on filings received by 18 March 2026 (an estimated 98.25% of property and casualty filings). The direct loss ratio is direct losses incurred divided by direct premiums earned. Headquarters are each group's business address on SEC EDGAR or, for Farmers, Auto Club Enterprises and CSAA, the home office in the California Department of Insurance's examination reports; for Sentry, NJM and Amica, the company's own website; for Travelers, the principal executive office on its 10-K. The 10-K column is from each group's EDGAR filing history.

The industry wrote $371.0 billion of private passenger auto premium in 2025. The top five wrote 65.14% of it, the top ten 76.88% and the top 25 88.68%, which leaves $42.0 billion for every other group and single company.

What the ranking shows

State Farm and Progressive are level. State Farm wrote $69.16 billion and Progressive $69.01 billion, a gap of $158 million. Progressive's written premium ran 2.6% above its earned premium while State Farm's ran 0.3% below, a rough sign of which book is growing (our reading of the NAIC figures). Progressive's 10-K says direct sales made up 57% of its personal vehicle volume in 2025, up from 55% in 2024.

Loss ratios vary more than shares. The industry incurred 61.49 cents of direct losses for every dollar of premium earned. Among the top five, Allstate was lowest at 55.64% and USAA highest at 67.35%. The Automobile Club of Michigan group (82.88%), Erie (73.05%) and NJM (70.20%) had the hardest years in the top 25; Liberty Mutual (47.17%), Farmers (51.49%) and Nationwide (51.59%) the easiest. A direct loss ratio leaves out most claims handling costs, commissions and overhead, so it isn't a combined ratio.

Some books are growing and some shrinking. Comparing written with earned premium (our calculation): NJM wrote 6.6% more than it earned, Auto Club Enterprises 3.9% and Progressive 2.6%. Liberty Mutual wrote 6.6% less, Nationwide 5.5% less and American Family 3.4% less. A carrier writing well above its earned premium is adding policies or raising rates, and may need more claims and service capacity to match.

Most of the market files no 10-K. Sixteen of the 25 groups don't file one, and together they wrote 42.22% of the market. Several are reciprocal exchanges rather than stock companies: Erie Insurance Exchange, a Pennsylvania reciprocal managed by the listed Erie Indemnity, and CSAA Insurance Exchange and the Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club, which California's examiners describe as reciprocal insurers. Their results come from statutory filings and their own releases, not SEC reports.

The largest commercial auto insurers

Commercial auto (trucks, vans and company cars) is a separate $77.1 billion market led by a different set of carriers:

RankGroupDirect premiums written, 2025Market shareDirect loss ratio
1Progressive$10.18B13.20%55.78%
2Travelers$4.21B5.46%62.29%
3Berkshire Hathaway$3.89B5.05%59.99%
4Old Republic$3.35B4.35%73.48%
5Liberty Mutual$2.80B3.64%67.11%
6State Farm$2.43B3.15%88.17%
7Zurich$2.42B3.14%73.30%
8Auto-Owners$2.19B2.84%55.75%
9AIG$1.75B2.27%66.18%
10The Hartford$1.68B2.18%69.47%

NAIC 2025 top 25 groups, total commercial auto. Industry direct loss ratio 66.81%.

Commercial auto is far less concentrated: the top ten wrote 45.27%, against 76.88% in personal auto. Its loss ratios run higher too: 66.81% for the industry against 61.49% in personal auto. Chubb (91.27%), State Farm (88.17%) and CNA (85.62%) had the highest loss ratios among the top 25 commercial writers, and State Farm's rose to 100.33% once defense and cost containment expenses were added. Fleet safety, dashcam and driver-training vendors sell into exactly that problem.

How the largest auto insurers sell

Distribution decides who you call about agents, marketing and quoting tools. In each company's own words:

GroupHow it sells
ProgressiveAgency 43% and direct 57% of personal vehicle volume in 2025, through "more than 40,000 independent insurance agencies" and its own direct channel
Berkshire Hathaway (GEICO)"Primarily through direct response methods", with applications submitted by internet or telephone, and to a lesser extent through insurance agencies
AllstateOver 27,400 Allstate exclusive agents and licensed sales professionals, about 58,700 independent agent locations and about 2,200 sales representatives in contact centers and online
Travelers"Primarily through thousands of independent agents and brokers", plus direct, affinity and carrier partnerships
Erie InsuranceIndependent agencies "serve as its sole distribution channel"
Mercury GeneralAbout 8,510 independent agents, which wrote about 88% of 2025 direct premiums; 82.1% of its premiums were written in California
CSAA"Primarily writes private passenger automobile and homeowners coverage in Northern California and markets to AAA members"
SentryPersonal lines sold under The General brand, which offers nonstandard auto insurance

From each company's 2025 10-K, except CSAA (California Department of Insurance examination report) and Sentry (its website).

Independent agencies sell for many carriers at once, so a tool that wins agency staff can spread across carriers. Agencies are classified under NAICS 524210; see the insurance agency NAICS code to build a list of them.

How this list is built

  • Premiums written are what policyholders were charged in 2025 for private passenger auto liability and physical damage, before reinsurance, from each insurer's statutory annual statement as compiled by the NAIC.
  • Groups, not brands. Each row combines every insurer in the group, as the NAIC defines it. Berkshire Hathaway's row is mostly GEICO, whose "principal business is the sale of private passenger automobile insurance", according to Berkshire's 10-K.
  • Countrywide means US states and territories, Canada and aggregate other alien business. The NAIC figures were based on about 98.25% of filings, so final totals can move slightly.
  • Loss ratios use direct losses incurred over direct premiums earned. The NAIC also publishes a ratio including defense and cost containment expenses: 63.36% for the industry in personal auto.
  • Left out: state-by-state rankings, which state insurance departments publish, and rankings by net premiums or revenue. Consumer comparison sites quote the same NAIC data; AM Best and S&P Global publish their own rankings, which we didn't use.

Where the buying happens at an auto insurer

General guidance, with the carriers to start with drawn from the data above.

What you sellWho usually buysWhere to start
Claims tools, repair networks, glass, rental, salvageAuto physical damage and claims operations leaders, with vendor managementHigh loss ratios: Automobile Club of Michigan group, Erie, NJM, Auto Club Enterprises
Telematics, pricing and underwriting dataAuto product and pricing leaders, actuarial teamsGrowing books: NJM, Auto Club Enterprises, Progressive, CSAA
Agency software, quoting and marketing for agentsDistribution and agency management leadersIndependent-agent carriers: Erie, Mercury, Travelers and Progressive's agency channel
Digital marketing and contact center servicesDirect marketing and customer experience leadersDirect writers: GEICO, Progressive's direct channel, Allstate's contact centers
Fleet safety and commercial auto dataCommercial auto underwriting leadersProgressive, Travelers, Old Republic and the commercial writers with high loss ratios

Worked example

Illustrative example. The vendor and its pricing are fictional; premiums and loss ratios are from the NAIC's 2025 private passenger auto table.

Claimlight (claimlight.example) sells photo-based damage estimating and repair shop routing for auto physical damage claims, at an illustrative $1.2 million a year per mid-sized carrier. Rather than start with the top five, Claimlight looks for carriers ranked 9 to 25 that are growing and losing more than the industry's 61.49%.

  1. Filter the table. Five groups wrote more than they earned and had loss ratios above 61.49%: Auto Club Enterprises, Erie, CSAA, NJM and The Hanover.
  2. Size the losses. Direct losses incurred are the loss ratio times earned premium. For Erie that's 73.05% of $5.17 billion, about $3.78 billion; for the five groups together, about $13.6 billion (our calculation).
  3. Do the arithmetic. If faster, more accurate estimates cut auto losses by an illustrative 0.5%, Erie would save about $18.9 million a year, more than 15 times the fee. Across the five groups it's about $68 million.
  4. Find the buyers. The head of auto physical damage claims owns the problem, claims operations runs the pilot, and vendor management approves the contract. Start with a pilot in one state.

The list Claimlight needs is these carriers, plus the agencies that sell for them, with the claims, distribution or procurement lead at each. At volume, that research is the slow part; Bebop builds the list and researches each account.

Next step: see the carriers and agencies in one state, starting with insurance companies in Illinois, home to State Farm, Allstate, Kemper and COUNTRY Financial.

Sources

Written by the Bebop team at Blackpearl Group. Published .

Questions people ask

What is the largest auto insurance company in the US?

State Farm, narrowly. It wrote $69.16 billion of private passenger auto premium in 2025, an 18.64% market share, according to the NAIC. Progressive was $158 million behind at $69.01 billion and 18.60%. Berkshire Hathaway's group, mainly GEICO, was third with $42.91 billion, followed by Allstate ($37.67 billion) and USAA ($22.96 billion).

What are the top 10 car insurance companies by market share?

By 2025 private passenger auto premiums written, per the NAIC: State Farm (18.64%), Progressive (18.60%), Berkshire Hathaway, mainly GEICO (11.56%), Allstate (10.15%), USAA (6.19%), Farmers (3.57%), Liberty Mutual (2.81%), Travelers (1.93%), Auto Club Enterprises (1.90%) and American Family (1.53%). Together they wrote 76.88% of the $371.0 billion market, and the top five alone wrote 65.14%.

Is GEICO bigger than Progressive?

No. In 2025 private passenger auto premiums, Progressive wrote $69.01 billion (18.60% of the market) and Berkshire Hathaway's insurance group, whose auto business is mainly GEICO, wrote $42.91 billion (11.56%), according to the NAIC. GEICO sells primarily direct, by internet and telephone. Progressive sells both direct and through more than 40,000 independent agencies, with direct making up 57% of its personal vehicle volume in 2025.

Who is the largest commercial auto insurer?

Progressive, with $10.18 billion of commercial auto premiums written in 2025 and a 13.20% market share, per the NAIC. Travelers ($4.21 billion, 5.46%), Berkshire Hathaway ($3.89 billion), Old Republic ($3.35 billion) and Liberty Mutual ($2.80 billion) follow. Commercial auto is a $77.1 billion market, and its top ten groups wrote only 45.27% of it.

Which auto insurers sell through independent agents?

Erie's 10-K says independent agencies are its sole distribution channel. Mercury General sells through about 8,510 independent agents, who wrote about 88% of its 2025 premiums. Travelers sells primarily through independent agents and brokers. Progressive works with more than 40,000 independent agencies, which brought 43% of its personal vehicle volume in 2025, and Allstate reaches about 58,700 independent agent locations alongside its exclusive agents.

How big is the US auto insurance market?

Insurers wrote $371.0 billion of private passenger auto premium and $77.1 billion of commercial auto premium in 2025, about $448 billion together, according to NAIC data based on filings received by 18 March 2026. Personal auto paid out 61.49% of earned premium in direct losses and commercial auto 66.81%, before most claims handling costs, commissions and overhead.

Reach the claims leader

Describe the carriers you sell to and the role you need. Bebop finds the insurers and agencies, names the claims, distribution or procurement lead and drafts the outreach.

Edit the search to match your market. Already have an account? Log in